•  
  •  
 

Abstract

Pelagic sharks are highly vulnerable components of oceanic tuna longline bycatch, yet many stocks remain difficult to assess because information is fishery-dependent, spatially uneven, taxonomically inconsistent, and dominated by zero-catch observations. This review synthesizes recent progress in data-limited assessment for pelagic sharks, emphasizing Taiwanese distant-water longline data and regional fisheries management organization (RFMO) scientific processes. Current best practice is shifting from isolated indicators toward tiered, risk-based frameworks that combine standardized catch-per-unit-effort, spatiotemporal generalized linear mixed models, length- and catch-based indicators, ecological risk assessment, Bayesian tools, and management strategy evaluation. Taiwan provides a useful case because its fleets operate across the Pacific, Indian, and Atlantic Oceans and generate logbook, observer, electronic logbook, and emerging electronic monitoring data for blue, mako, hammerhead, silky, oceanic whitetip, and thresher sharks. Assessment reliability will improve when species-level reporting, observer and electronic monitoring coverage, biological sampling, discard-fate estimation, and transparent uncertainty treatment are strengthened. The same evidence base is increasingly needed for CITES Non-Detriment Findings, Important Shark and Ray Area interpretation, RFMO bycatch measures, and precautionary high-seas governance. Its principal contribution is an explicitly conceptual decision framework that begins with the management objective, evaluates evidence quality and bias, and selects the least complex assessment tier capable of producing defensible advice. Data-limited assessment should therefore be treated as a structured basis for defensible management under imperfect information, not as a weaker substitute for conventional stock assessment.

Abstract Image

Highlights

  1. Begin with the management objective, then match the assessment tier to the weakest decision-critical evidence.
  2. Treat CPUE standardization as a hypothesis about fleet behavior, catchability, and spatial sampling.
  3. Use observer and electronic monitoring data to verify species identity, fate, and discard mortality.
  4. Taiwanese multi-ocean longline data can connect national monitoring with RFMO and CITES decisions.

COinS